It’s hard to pick my very favourite episode of ‘Scrubs’. I can pick my least favourite in a second (’My Night to Remember, ep 6.11), but favourite is harder to come by. Gun to my head though, after much consideration, I think I’d have to go with these five. ‘Scrubs’ was always a master of a genre that I simply term ‘frownsmile’. It’s a category of television that is rare, but rarely disappointing. Frownsmile is the ability to make you feel incredibly depressed, and incredibly happy at the same time. Frownsmile television (and for that matter, film) has the ability to change the mood from humour to pure sadness in an instant.
My Screw-Up (ep 3.14)
“Where do you think we are?” -J.D.
My Screw-Up is frownsmile at its best. This episode, which pays homage to the film ‘The Sixth Sense’, is incredibly well written and directed. It begins with the re-introduction of Ben (Brendan Fraser) as Cox’s best friend and brother-in-law, who has avoided all contact with doctors since the remission of his leukemia. Unbeknownst to viewers, Ben succumbs to his disease very early on in the episode, and it is they who carry Cox’s personal denial of the loss of his best friend. The direction is superb, with dozens of subtle hints leading viewers along one path, and only crushing them at the episodes tear-jerking conclusion in one of the finest scenes of the series, beautifully accompanied by Josh Radin’s ‘Winter’.
It gives you the laughs that you expect from ‘Scrubs’, combined with the drama and deep moments that made the series one of the best shows on television. This episode shows Dr. Cox’s sensitive side, and shows his vulnerability, simultaneously strengthening the relationship between J.D. and Dr. Cox. For me, it’s not even about the big moments, the final reveal and the devastation on Cox’s face as those who love him begin to fill the surrounding seats at the funeral. It’s the small things (like J.D.’s putting his hand on Cox’s shoulder, and him accepting it) that carry the episode for me, and make the ending all that more real.
My Super Ego (ep 1.07)
“That kid is eventually gonna die. Whether it’s today, or tomorrow, or a month from now. There’s nothing I can do; nothing works. Now his parents want to talk to me, what am I supposed to tell them — “Peter lived a good, long seven years”? Seven years, man! It’s not fair. I hate this place. I hate this job— I can’t do it anymore. I–I’m done…I’m done…I’m done.”
It was difficult for me to decide between this episode and ‘My Old Lady’ (ep 1.04), because both are really what made me lose my heart to the series. Ultimately though, I chose this episode, largely on account of the phenomenal performance as Dr Nick Murdoch by ‘Will and Grace’’s Sean Hayes.
J.D is finally rising to the top and becoming noticed as a great intern when Nick breaks onto the scene, and he completely steals the show. Nick is incredibly likable, to both the characters, and us as viewers. His energy and passion seems second to none, and that is exactly why we become so heart-broken when the pressures of being a doctor prove too much for Nick when he has to tell a child’s parents that he will not be getting better. Elliot and JD find Nick in a stairwell crying, and he admits that the pressure is overwhelming to him. He quits.
I love this episode, not only for the comedic moments in it, but for the realness it brings. The story is about the fact that we all need to deal with things in different ways, and that ultimately, even the best of us fail. The most devastating part of the episode, for me at least, is the fact that when Nick finally lays his heart bare, destroyed, Elliot and J.D. are helpless to find the right words to help him.
My Life in Four Cameras (ep 4.17)
“Unfortunately, around here things don’t always end as neat and tidy as they do in sitcoms. Relationships aren’t always magically fixed in thirty minutes — you have to work on them. Problems don’t always have easy solutions, and around here, nice people don’t always get better…and at times like that, it’s comforting to know there’s always one thing that can pick your spirits up.”
In another display of epic frownsmile, ‘My Life in Four Cameras’ scrapes in to my top five. Looking at reviews online, it surprises me that, as a rule, interpretations seem to be incredibly superficial. Ultimately, this episode is about J.D. dealing with the unpleasantness of death, through fantasy. It portrays two parallel worlds, that of what we consider to be the general ‘Scrubs’ ‘reality’, and that which ‘Scrubs’ would be more likely to be if it had been a four camera live sitcom (one that is obviously implausible). The episode brings new meaning to J.D’s fixation with fantasy, not simply for his amusement, but as his coping device. In reality, JD knows that the story is a tragedy, and not a comedy, but he remains optimistic, even when indulged with circumstances where success seems to be too good to be true. It is amazing how this episode shows the actuality of life. How “sitcoms” are ultimately bastardised reality, cut and pressed until they are fit for painless human consumption. How things that can be solved in half an hour clear are actually infinitely more complicated than they are portrayed. Ultimately, this episode ,”My Life in Four Cameras” is in fact an amazing exemplification of real life. Our actions and perceptions do not always follow a nice, linear pattern of narrative, and that’s why we, like J.D., need fantasy to exist, as a form of escapism, a form of closure, and a form of happiness inducing entertainment.
My Lunch (ep 5.20)
J.D.: Remember what you told me? The second you start blaming yourself for peoples’ deaths there’s no coming back.
Dr. Cox: Yeah, you’re right.
‘My Lunch’ contains what is possibly John C. McGuinley’s (Dr Cox) best performance of the series, as well as what has become an incredibly overused piece of music ‘How to Save a Life’ by ‘The Fray’. Despite the latter, the episode is still a defining moment in television, beautifully shot and powerfully performed. The episode follows Cox’s desperate attempts to track down organs for three patients, and his support for J.D. after he feels ultimately responsible for a patient’s death. The tables turn when the organs acquired for the patients carry a disease that leads to their deaths, and Cox is the one in need of support. It’s incredible to me that such powerful emotion is crammed into 21 minutes of screen time, and the writing and quality of acting that this episode holds is nothing short of amazing, and seeing the strongest character in the series walk out the door of the hospital brought me to tears. The episode’s only misfortune is The Todd’s B-story, which is entirely misplaced amongst the misery.
His Story III (ep 5.19)
“I’m not kidding myself. I know I don’t have the most important job in the world, but I work in a place that helps people, and I always thought that I was part of that… Who cares?”
It’s probably not difficult to notice that my two favourite characters in ‘Scrubs’ are Dr Cox and The Janitor. As the series progressed, I found that my interest focused even moreso on those two. Maybe it’s an odd ‘repressed emotion’ thing, or a ‘root for the underdog’ thing, but it occurred to me on several occasions that I’d be entirely happy to watch a series called ‘Dr Cox and Janitor’. Imagine my delight when J.D. is locked in a water tower, and thus passes his narration on to the Janitor.
One of only eight episodes not narrated by Braff (J.D.), it stands out regardless of quality. The Janitor’s plan in this episode is to prove that he contributes to the world, and that he can make a difference. When he inadvertently overhears several doctors discussing the fact that he makes no impact upon the world, and then proceed to pity him, he sets about to fix the computer of a quadriplegic patient (Mr McNair) suffering from ‘locked in’ syndrome. Ultimately, he’s not much of a handyman, and the computer is destroyed.
What makes this episode great is that we finally get to see the workings of the Janitor’s mind. We realise how much pride he does take in working at the hospital, and learn that he wants to make an impact, and not just be seen as the guy with the mop. The episode ends with JD being released from the tank and taking over narration. Mr. McNair gets his computer back and thanks the Janitor for being there, the first real show of the appreciation he’s seen in a while. No one dies, the episode doesn’t end in tragedy, but the emotion in such a simple ‘thank you’ is some of the most powerful on television.
So that’s my list. It’s far from perfect. Those are my favourites this week, and yeah – they’re all tear-jerkers. Honorable mentions have to go to ‘My Way Home’, ‘My Bed Banter and Beyond’, ‘My Catalyst’ and ‘My Occurrence’. Ultimately I could sit here typing all night, but no one would read it.